March 28, 2025: Voucher Math 101


Header reads: Texas A-F-T. The Hotline.

Friday, March 28, 2025

Math teacher Tay Carriker-Cavin standing in front of calk board with voucher math 101 written.


Voucher Math 101


On Tuesday, while Gov. Greg Abbott (bafflingly) hosted Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey to promote his private school voucher scheme, fifth-grade math teacher Tay Carriker-Cavin, an Education Austin member, delivered a tough lesson in “Voucher Math” just feet away from their press conference. 

Armed with a chalkboard and the truth about Arizona’s voucher disaster, Carriker-Cavin broke down the devastating math of Arizona’s program, which has created a $1.4 billion budget shortfall and forced deep cuts to essential services while primarily benefiting rich families with children already in private school. See a list of verified purchases with Arizona & Florida voucher money. 

In a statement, Texas AFT President Zeph Capo noted the head-scratching nature of Abbott’s outreach to Ducey to help him assuage concerns from Texans and their lawmakers about this unaccountable cash grab:  

It’s certainly a choice to lock arms with the man who signed into law the signature piece of legislation that has bankrupted his state. If Ducey is proud that his state has diverted money from water infrastructure to fund the purchase of $10,000 sewing machines or ski passes for families using vouchers, that’s his business. But I feel confident in saying that’s not what Texans want, not when our public schools are closing campuses, laying off staff, and cutting bus routes to cover their own state-manufactured budget deficits.”   

In this week’s Hotline:  

  • Student discipline bills take center stage
  • Follow the money on vouchers
  • Good higher education bills! 
  • A non-comprehensive list of what is happening with the Department of Education 



Despite two-thirds of Texans opposing his private school voucher program (29% support, 65% oppose), Gov. Greg Abbott held a press conference this week alongside Lt. Gov.Dan Patrick and House Speaker Dustin Burrows, declaring he had the votes to pass House Bill 3, his latest voucher scheme. 

Abbott also announced that the House Public Education Committee will vote on HB 3 next week (we’ll see). In a bizarre move, he invited former Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey to speak about Arizona’s disastrous voucher program, which created a $1.4 billion budget shortfall and forced deep cuts to essential services — all while primarily benefiting wealthy families with children already in private school. 


Gov. Greg Abbott’s focus on failed voucher programs ignores the real needs of Texas public schools. We urge supporters of public schools to call keep calling the members of the House Public Education Committee and tell them ‘Hell No!’ to voucher scams.  



Take Action 



A great way to make your voice heard on bills in the state Legislature is to leave a public comment online. These comments, which you can write from your home, are distributed to representatives on House committees and become part of the public record on a bill – so be respectful and thoughtful when writing. Refer to the online story for bills Texas AFT encourages public school supporters to leave comments on this week. 


Despite Gov. Greg Abbott and billionaire donor Jeff Yass pouring millions into pro-voucher campaigns, the public remains firmly against privatizing our schools. 

Texas AFT President Zeph Capo brought the receipts this week to a press conference with Local Progress Texas, a coalition of local government officials and community partners working to advance racial and economic justice for Texans across the state. Watch what he had to say & share with your networks. 




—Higher Education

House Higher Ed Committee Off to a Good Start  

After last week’s Senate Bill 37 chaos in the Senate Education K-16 Committee, it was refreshing to see bills in the House Higher Education Committee that would support our community colleges and universities. 

Those bills, HB 2110, HB 1330, and HJR 5 were all voted out of committee on Thursday. 


— Higher Education



AFT members, parents, and students gather outside the Department of Education on March 14 to protest the Trump Administration’s move to gut the department and imperil federal funding for our kids and their schools. 

AFT Takes Legal Action to Defend Public, Higher Education 


This week, AFT is fighting back against Trump’s executive order to dismantle the U.S. Department of Education. In a new lawsuit filed in Massachusetts, AFT joined educators, school districts, and unions nationwide to challenge the legality of the executive order and defend the very existence of the Department of Education (DOE). As AFT President Randi Weingarten put it: 

 

“Trying to abolish the department as one of the president’s first acts—whether through an executive order, a ‘reduction in force’ or concepts of a plan to shift services elsewhere—is not only illegal, it sends a message that the president doesn’t care about broad-based opportunity, doesn’t care about knowledge, and doesn’t care about this country’s future.” 


Recommended Reading

Education news from around the state and nation that’s worth your time.

📖 Texas officials’ claim that school funding is at an all-time high ignores inflation and temporary federal money. A Tribune analysis also found the state’s share of the funds that schools receive per student significantly decreased in the last decade until recently. (Texas Tribune, March 28)  

📖 Texas Senate passes bill to fund safer railroad crossings after Houston ISD student’s death. Senate Bill 1555, co-authored by a Houston Democrat and East Texas Republican, would create a $350 million grant program to fund grade separation projects at the intersections of railroads and roadways. (Houston Public Media, March 26)  

📖 How did Texas school districts vote on school chaplain programs? Here’s the data. A 2023 law – Senate Bill 763 – required all Texas school districts to vote on whether to employ chaplains or create a volunteer chaplain program to provide student support services, much like a school counselor. (Austin American-Statesman, March 27)